New Plymouth Homes under $400,000

Welcome to New Plymouth, Idaho—a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Payette County. This charming city, with its rich agricultural heritage and breathtaking landscapes, offers a unique blend of small-town warmth and modern conveniences. Known for its friendly community and picturesque surroundings, New Plymouth is the perfect place for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a peaceful lifestyle.

One of the most appealing aspects of New Plymouth is its affordability. The real estate market here boasts a variety of homes under $400,000, making it an ideal destination for first-time buyers or those looking to downsize without compromising on quality. Whether you’re searching for a cozy single-family home, a charming cottage, or a spacious property with room to grow, you’ll find a diverse selection of listings that cater to different tastes and budgets.

New Plymouth is also conveniently located near stunning outdoor attractions, including the Payette River and the scenic foothills of the Treasure Valley. Residents enjoy a wealth of recreational activities, from hiking and fishing to biking and camping. The city is home to excellent schools, local parks, and a vibrant downtown area filled with quaint shops and eateries, ensuring that all your needs are just a stone’s throw away.

If you’re ready to discover the charm of New Plymouth and explore the incredible homes available under $400,000, you’re just a click away from finding your dream home in this welcoming community. Embrace the Idaho lifestyle and make New Plymouth your new home today!

Newest New Plymouth Homes under $400,000

$399,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 99002982 MLS

Enjoy the space and flexibility of country-style living with the convenience of being in town! This 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom home offers 1,943 square feet on a generous .85-acre lot in New Plymouth. The property is zoned Residential-C with multi-family duplex potential, offering an added layer of flexibility for buyers looking for future possibilities, subject to city requirements and approvals. The property already has plenty to offer, including a large insulated shop with power and 2x6 construction—ideal for projects, hobbies, equipment, or storage. There’s also a chicken coop, lean-to, pasture area, and fenced space in the back, giving you room to enjoy gardening, outdoor projects, animals, or simply having more space to spread out. Inside, central heat and air provide year-round comfort, while the wood stove offers an additional heat source during the colder months. Step outside to the covered back patio and take in the peaceful surroundings. With nearly an acre, useful outbuildings, flexible zoning, and a true small-town Idaho feel, this property offers an uncommon opportunity to enjoy space and versatility right in New Plymouth.

143 S East Blvd, New Plymouth

$359,995

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 99002824 MLS

Unlock your "Life Upgrade" with rates as low as 4.25% PLUS a refrigerator, washer & dryer now through October 31st! Ask a Sales Specialist for details. This brand new home located in vibrant New Plymouth, Idaho welcomes you with open arms. The Chandler 1447 offers a warm and refined living experience with an open layout designed for comfort and ease. At the front of the home, two well-situated bedrooms create flexible spaces for hosting or a dedicated workspace, while the spacious kitchen features modern amenities, generous counter space, and a large island that enhances everyday cooking. The great room feels bright and inviting, creating an effortless flow throughout the main living area. Tucked away at the rear of the home, the primary suite offers a private retreat with its en suite bath and an expansive closet. Outdoor spaces extend your living area, providing a relaxing spot for fresh air and quiet moments. With thoughtful design and a seamless layout, the Chandler 1447 brings comfort, style, and convenience together beautifully. **PHOTOS ARE SIMILAR**. All selections are subject to change without notice, please call to verify.

606 Rosemary Ave, New Plymouth

$275,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 99001671 MLS

TWO houses zoned Residential B Single Family Duplex on almost 1/2 an acre on the coveted Horseshoe! First house has 3 beds, 1 bathroom and 1076sf. The detached dwelling has 1 bed 1 bath and is 616sf. Awesome opportunity to own and create passive income or easing up your mortgage payment by renting out the second home. Previous owner rented the property for 18 years. Main house needs some updating and a little love but have been spruced up with updated windows and newer siding.

277 & 279 S East Blvd, New Plymouth

$389,990

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 99001339 MLS

Unlock your "Life Upgrade" with rates as low as 4.25% PLUS a refrigerator, washer & dryer now through October 31st! Ask a Sales Specialist for details. Embrace the comforts of a brand new home in New Plymouth, Idaho. The Bennett 1694 offers refined single-level living with a flexible layout that places the kitchen, living room, and primary suite at the rear of the home for a peaceful, private feel. The kitchen features a spacious island with plenty of room to create, while large living room windows bring in beautiful natural light and a bright, inviting atmosphere. Easy access to the patio allows for effortless indoor-outdoor enjoyment. The primary suite feels like a serene retreat, thoughtfully positioned apart from the additional bedrooms, and the flex room adds valuable space that can adapt to your lifestyle. With its smart design and comfortable flow, the Bennett delivers single-level living at its finest. **PHOTOS ARE SIMILAR**. All selections are subject to change without notice, please call to verify.

601 Rosemary Ave, New Plymouth

$379,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 98994932 MLS

Be the first to call this beautiful new construction home your own. Scheduled for completion in August, this thoughtfully designed home offers 3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and a 2-car garage, providing the perfect blend of comfort and functionality. Ideally located in town, you'll enjoy the convenience of being just steps away from local schools and downtown. Inside, you'll find an open, inviting floor plan designed for modern living. Large windows fill the home with natural light. The kitchen opens up to the dining and living room and features stainless steel appliances and quartz countertops. The primary bedroom offers an ensuite bathroom and walk-in closet. Two additional bedrooms and another bathroom are perfect for family, guests, or a home office. The attached 2-car garage provides a space for vehicles, storage, and hobbies. Whether you're a first-time homebuyer or someone looking to downsize, this property is an exceptional value at $389,000. Reserve your new home today and be ready to move in this August!

209 E Elm, New Plymouth

$364,995

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 98981567 MLS

Unlock your "Life Upgrade" with rates as low as 4.25% PLUS a refrigerator, washer & dryer now through October 31st! Ask a Sales Specialist for details. This new home located in beautiful New Plymouth, Idaho has all the comforts you need & more! The Olivia 1522 lives up to its beautiful name with a layout that feels perfectly sized and thoughtfully designed. The split bedroom arrangement places two bedrooms at the front of the home while the primary suite enjoys a quiet position of its own. Vaulted ceilings and an open living room create an inviting space for hosting, and the kitchen island allows you to cook and stay connected with guests at the same time. Generous counter space and modern appliances make meal prep effortless. The primary suite is a peaceful retreat from the day with an elegant en suite bath and a spacious closet. With a layout that maximizes comfort and usability, the Olivia blends charm, style, and practicality in every corner. Photos are of the actual home!

511 Pine St, New Plymouth

$384,995

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 98979343 MLS

Unlock your "Life Upgrade" with rates as low as 4.25% PLUS a refrigerator, washer & dryer now through October 31st! Ask a Sales Specialist for details. Embrace the comforts of a brand new home in New Plymouth, Idaho. The Harrison 2025 delivers single-level living at its finest with a bright, sunlit living room positioned at the rear of the home to create a calm and inviting retreat. The kitchen island encourages culinary creativity and easy gathering, while the concrete patio offers a seamless way to enjoy fresh air. The primary suite feels like a private escape with its elegant en suite bath featuring dual vanities, refreshing natural light, and an expansive closet for effortless storage. Spacious additional bedrooms and a thoughtfully arranged layout enhance comfort throughout, and a dedicated laundry room adds convenience to your daily routine. Designed with modern living in mind, the Harrison 2025 brings together style, ease, and refined simplicity. Potential RV parking available. Photos are of the actual home!

600 Rosemary Ave, New Plymouth

$376,995

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 98979344 MLS

Unlock your "Life Upgrade" with rates as low as 4.25% PLUS a refrigerator, washer & dryer now through October 31st! Ask a Sales Specialist for details. Feel enriched in your brand new home located in New Plymouth, Idaho! The Willow 1860 offers a beautifully designed single level layout with two bedrooms situated at the front of the home for a peaceful sense of separation. The vaulted great room and dining area create an airy, inviting space that opens to the back patio, perfect for both entertaining and quiet relaxation. Natural light pours through the windows, highlighting the height and openness of the vaulted ceiling. The well-appointed kitchen provides ample counter space, modern appliances, and an island ideal for everyday meals or casual hosting. The primary suite serves as a restful retreat with a roomy en suite bathroom, dual vanities, a stand-up shower, and a generous closet. With its open design, thoughtful storage, and elegant flow, the Willow 1860 brings comfort and functionality together in a truly elevated way. Photos are of the actual home!

602 Rosemary Ave, New Plymouth

Start Your Search

The content relating to real estate for sale on this site comes in part from the IDX program of the RMLS of Portland, Oregon. Real Estate listings held by brokerage firms other than this firm are marked with the RMLS logo, and detailed information about these properties include the name of the listing's broker. Listing content is copyright © 2026 RMLS of Portland, Oregon. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. This content last updated on . Some properties which appear for sale on this web site may subsequently have sold or may no longer be available.

Information courtesy of Intermountain Multiple Listing Service. Information provided by IMLS is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non‐commercial use, it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. IMLS does not assume any liability for missing or inaccurate data. All listings provided by IMLS are marked with the official IMLS IDX icon.